Received date: July 24, 2017; Accepted date: August 04, 2017; Published date: August 07, 2017
Citation: Rodríguez-Hernández JM, Camelo-Tovar F, Albavera-Hernández C, Campuzano-Rincón JC. Motorcyclists’ Mortality Pattern in Colombia from 2000 to 2013: A Longitudinal Study. Arch Med. 2017, 9:4. doi: 10.21767/1989-5216.1000228
Copyright: © 2017 Rodríguez-Hernández JM, et al. This is an open-access article distributed under the terms of the Creative Commons Attribution License, which permits unrestricted use, distribution, and reproduction in any medium, provided the original author and source are credited.
Background: Road traffic injuries and fatalities have increased in Colombia despite that 2011-2020 had been declared as the Decade of Action for Road Safety in the world. Then, this paper aims to describe the trends of motorcycle mortality patterns in Colombia from 2000-2013.
Methods: A longitudinal study is carried out using mortality records from the Colombian National Department of Statistics, and following the International Classification of Diseases -ICD-10 V200 to V299.
Results: From 2000 to 2013 the study founded a near 100% increase in the number of motorcycle fatalities in Colombia; the occurrence rate increased from 3.6 to 5.7 per 100,000 populations. 65.4% of the fatalities involve individuals from 15 to 34 years of age.
Conclusions: Motorcycle fatalities have become a serious public health issue in Colombia. For the 14-year of the study period, slightly more than 28,800 motorcyclist’s deaths have been attributed to different factors and social determinants.
Motorcycles; Colombia; Mortality rates; Decade of action for road safety
The 2004 World Report from the World Health Organization states that the Road Traffic Injury (RTI) is becoming an ever growing public health issue . According to the report, related road traffic disasters represent the number one cause of death due to injury, the eleventh cause in the general mortality population, and it is ranked the ninth cause in the global burden of disease . The report also shows that around 1.3 million of population worldwide loses their lives every year due to road traffic injuries, and the Western Hemisphere is far from being the exception, as nearly 150,000 fatalities per year are confirmed . In 2010, Latin America had an average rate of 16.3 per 100,000 populations, practically twice the average shown in countries where population earned a high income, which revealed rates of around 10 per 100,000 populations. A problem that is widely outpacing the average registered in countries such as Denmark (3.5), Australia (5.4), Germany (4.3), France (5.1), Ireland (4.1), Japan (4.7), Canada (6.0), United States (10.6) . Projected estimations show that by 2020 the average rate in the Latin America region could be reaching 24/100,000 population. If this prediction comes to pass, it would represent a true challenge to the economic and social development of the countries comprising this region [3,5].
The expenditure due to crashes and health care services for those traffic injuries are estimated to be around 1% of the gross domestic product (GDP) in low-income, 1.5% in middle-income countries, and 2% in high income countries. Healthcare costs due to RTI are estimated to represent between 1.6% to 4.2% of Colombia’s GDP in 2010 .
Although in recent years the global mortality rate due to RTI has decreased, in most Latin American and Caribbean countries this reduction has not been evenly distributed among road users. The study conducted by Rodrigues et al.  shows that the motorcyclists’ fatal injury pattern increased on the entire continent from 1998 to 2010, especially for the Andean subregion countries. The study also reported that the increasing of the mortality-rate might be a result of recent economic changes, a rapid increase in motorization rates, and a lack of public transportation policies oriented to the need of discouraging the use of private vehicles [6,7]. In addition, factors such as the growth in motorcycle sales, higher cost of fuel for regular 4- wheels vehicles, and the generalized idea-along with the misleading conception that motorcycles are more environmental friendly (among others) have also been related to this increasing phenomenon [8-19].
Moreover, it has also been corroborated by several authors that in low-income countries the high incidence of mortality rate is a result of several circumstances, such as negligible use of personal protective equipment, slight low enforcement, frequent breach of traffic laws, driving at high speeds, culture of diving in zigzag patterns, use of cell phones while driving, and low perception of risk on unsafe driving conditions with little traffic signals [20-29].
Thus, regarding to the Colombian’ situation, this country occupies the fourth position in South America’s territorial extension, and the third in population growth in Latin America, after Brazil and Mexico; and according to the National Administrative Department of Statistics , the country had a population of 47'120,770 inhabitants in 2013, living in 33 decentralized territorial provinces . Colombia also has the fourth largest regional GDP, and among the whole world the country is ranked in the 30th position. Particular condition that partially allows to explain the increase in purchasing fourwheels, and primarily, two-wheel vehicle; a trend that has been steadily happening for the last 10 years [32,33].
Among the 2000 to the 2013 year, Colombia increased considerably the number of registered motorcycle vehicles, coming from 32.8% to almost 50%, and virtually doubling the number of car in 29.0%, as a mean of transportation [34,35]. Similarly, in recent years, the participation of this type of vehicle in road accidents has shown a significantly growth, especially for deadly events ; that is, representing 24% of all road deaths in 2001 to around 45% in 2010 [37-39]. Therefore, this article aims to analyze the pattern of motorcyclists’ mortality for the Colombian population between the 2000 and 2013 year, following a list of variables from the official Colombian mortality registered records.
A longitudinal-descriptive study of motorcyclists’ mortality in Colombia from 2000 to 2013, using records from the Colombian National Administration Department of Statistics (DANE is the Colombian acronym), was implemented. The events classified as death due to motorcycle accidents were extracted from the mortality database using codes V20 to V29 according to the tenth edition of the International Classification of Diseases (ICD 10).
The variables analyzed for this study are: year (2000 to 2013), Month (January to December), Age (discrete variable from 0 to 99 years of age), Sex (Male, Female), causes according to ICD 10 codes (as mentioned above), and provincial and municipal locations —where the fatality took place. Similar to the large population groups, which have been used for the study of injuries and deaths from external causes [1,40], age-groups are gathered following specific categories (under 15, from 15 to 34, from 35 to 59, and 60 and over). Specific rates are also calculated for each year, based on the DANE’s population projections and reported per 100,000 populations.
As stated before, a longitudinal descriptive analysis was carried out from the 2000 to 2013 year. The specific mortality rates are calculated according to provincial, municipal, sex, and age-group data, from the first to the last year of the study period. To make better comparisons among different provinces and municipalities, adjusted mortality rates, using the direct standardization method with 95% confidence intervals, were obtained. Then, the same proportional distribution used by the WHO-2000 standard population was applied to each specific rate by age-groups, allowing, therefore, to make properly adjustments in population structure differences toward each compared groups .
Using that estimation, the mortality risk for each provincial territory is ranked as one out of five categories: very low (below the 10th percentile); low (from the 10th to the 25th percentile); average (from the 26th to the 75th percentile); high (from the 76th to the 90th percentile); and very high (over the 90th percentile). Additionally, the software used in the analyses was State 13.2 and Microsoft Excel 2013. The results of the study were also geo-referenced on maps, using the software ArcGIS version 10.4.
Finally, Poisson Regression was the model applied for this multivariate analysis, aimed at estimating the incidence of relative risk (IRR in the equations, using 95% confidence intervals (CI) and a p value<0.05). The general population is considered the exposure variable, with the dependent variable represented by the number of fatalities and the independent variables classified as: Sex (0=Female, 1=Male); Period (2000-2004=0, 2005-2008=1, 2009-2013=2); Age-Group (under 15=0, 15 to 34=1, 35 to 59=2, 60 and over=3); Provincial Territory (Antioquia=1, Bogotá=2, Valle del Cauca=3, Meta=4, Cesar=5, Guajira=6, Rest of the Country=0), and having in mind as well that other variables were used just for model adjustment purposes.
The present study did not require approval from any Ethics Committee, since according to the Law Act, Resolution 008430, from the Colombian Ministry of Health in 1993, this kind of research is considered to have no risk. The study is, exclusively, using secondary data, among which there is no personal information regarding to any deceased individual, and therefore, private information is not comprised.
From 2000 to 2013 fatal road traffic injuries took the lives of 24,881 motorcyclists, 86.6% of whom were men. But, during that period, while the standard rate of mortality due to RTI in Colombia dropped from 19.8 to 14.3 per 100,000 populations, motorcyclist fatalities increased steadily until becoming the number one cause of traffic fatalities, representing eventually nearly 40% of total traffic fatalities in 2013. In other words, the retrospective analysis clearly shows how much in a country like Colombia the annual motorcyclist fatalities increased constantly during the period of study. As can be seen on the annexed graph, from 2000 to 2005 there is a slight decrease of fatalities due to this cause, which is interrupted by a sudden increase in 2006, remaining steady until the end of the study period (Figure 1). The number of deceased persisted as to 1,800 fatalities per month with some peaks in June (8.7%) and in December (9.5%), probably associated with traffic increase during those vacation periods.
The age-group from 15 to 34 years contributed to the 65.4% of fatalities, particularly within the youth group aged 20 to 24 years whom comprised 20.7% of the cases. For the following age-groups there is evidence of a rapid decrease in the number of fatalities all the way down until the elderly group aged 60 to 64, who represented 1.4% of the fatalities. Yet, it is important to point out that similarities of 1,8% between the elderly group and motorcyclist’s fatalities under the 15-year-olds group were observed (Table 1). A little over 60% of all motorcyclist fatalities during the study period are located and concentrated in eight provincial territories: Antioquia (17.5%), Valle (15.2%), Bogotá (6.7%), Huila (5.1%), Santander (5.1%), Meta (4.4%), Tolima (4.3%), and Cundinamarca (4.2%). However, after adjusting the mortality rate per 100,000 populations, a different picture is shown; which is demonstrated by the fact that in 2013 the provincial territories had the following percentage: Casanare (22.1), Arauca (17.5), Huila (14.9), Meta (13.6), Cesar (12.9), Putumayo (9.7), Tolima (8.5), and Santander (6.5). Also, it is important to stand out that although Antioquia and Valle together gathered 33.7% of the fatalities, they have an average similar to the national rate of 5.7 per 100,000 populations.
|0 to 4 years||48||1,44||53||0,25||101||0,41|
|5 to 9 years||39||1,17||44||0,20||83||0,33|
|10 to 14 years||105||3,15||175||0,81||280||1,13|
|15 to 19 years||516||15,47||1939||9,00||2455||9,87|
|20 to 24 years||674||20,21||4488||20,83||5162||20,75|
|25 to 29 years||520||15,59||4367||20,27||4887||19,64|
|30 to 34 years||408||12,23||3195||14,83||3603||14,48|
|35 to 39 years||303||9,09||2299||10,67||2602||10,46|
|40 to 44 years||248||7,44||1665||7,73||1913||7,69|
|45 to 49 years||167||5,01||1204||5,59||1371||5,51|
|50 to 54 years||100||3,00||785||3,64||885||3,56|
|55 to 59 years||66||1,98||532||2,47||598||2,40|
|60 to 64 years||52||1,56||302||1,40||354||1,42|
|65 to 69 years||30||0,90||204||0,95||234||0,94|
|70 to 74 years||24||0,72||102||0,47||126||0,51|
|75 to 79 years||11||0,33||67||0,31||78||0,31|
|80 and more||14||0,42||65||0,30||79||0,32|
Table 1: Motorcyclists mortality by age groups. Colombia, 2000 to 2013 (Source: Colombian National Statistics Department 2013).
The increase in this phenomenon has been so dramatic that none of the 33 provincial territories showed a downward trend at all. During the 14-year study period, in some more than others, the Provincial Territories shown a pronounce upward increase. For instance, the provincial territory of Cesar increased its motorcyclist mortality rate by 426%, Putumayo by 314%, Casanare and Arauca by 253% and 230%, respectively.
As well, other provincial territories such as Norte de Santander, Boyacá, Risaralda, Cauca, Cundinamarca, Atlántico, Córdoba, Sucre, Nariño and Bolívar doubled the rate at which they started out from the study period (p<0.05) (Figure 2). Thus, after making the appropriate adjustment for the mortality rates by age and sex using the Poisson Model, the provincial territory that shown the greatest risk of deaths (for men) was San Andrés, with an IRR of 6.00 (CI 95%: 5.06 ± 7.13), followed by Casanare 3.07 (CI 95%: 3.38 ± 2.78), Arauca 2.88 (CI 95%: 3.29 ± 2.52) and Meta 2.1 (95% CI: 2.24 ± 1.96) (Figure 3).
Poisson Regression analysis showed that for this study period, the men group had a significantly higher risk of dying as motorcyclist, with a IRR 4.51 (95% CI 4.3 ± 4.7), compared to women, after carrying out adjustments for other independent variables included in the final model, such as age-groups, periods of time and provincial territories.
Likewise, compared with other age-groups, the analysis shows an increased risk of death among those aged 15-34, with a IRR of 8.74 (95% CI: 7.97 ± 9.60) and those aged 35-59 with a IRR 5.78 (95% CI 5.26-6.35). On the other hand, the analysis also suggested increased risk associated with time; since during the study period (2000-2013) there was an increase of 34% (95% CI 1.30 ± 1.38) throughout the country, when matched up to the category used as reference (2000-2004). Finally, when analyzed by provincial territories, during the study period of fourteen years, the risk of dying was higher in Meta, Cesar, Valle and Antioquia (p<0.001) (Table 2).
|Variable||RRI||CI 95 %||p value|
|15 to 34 years||8.74||7.97||9.6||<0001|
|35 to 59 years||5.78||5.26||6.35||<0001|
|≥ 60 years||4.17||3.72||4.67||<0001|
|2000 to 2004 (Ref)||1|
|2005 to 2008||1.09||1.06||1.13||<0001|
|2009 to 2013||1.34||1.3||1.38||<0001|
|Other departments (Ref)||1|
Table 2: Mortality risk among motorcyclists in Colombia 2000-2013 (Source: Own calculations using Colombian National Statistics Department data records 2013).
Between 2000-2013 there was a 94% increase in the number of deaths associated with motorcyclists in Colombia, having also the incidence-rate increase from 3.6 to 5.7 per 100.000 populations. Slightly more than 60% of the total mortality was concentrated in eight provincial territories (Antioquia, Valle, Bogota, Huila, Santander, Meta, Tolima, and Cundinamarca). However, compared with the national average (p<0.05), the adjusted mortality rates in states such as Arauca, Casanare, Huila have shown a significantly increase in the study period (Figure 2). The motorcycle mortality seems to be concentrated in states with greater economic income, which is consistent with better regional road infrastructure and higher number of registered vehicle [29,33,42-48].
The high mortality growth in states such as Casanare, Meta and Cesar, in which adjusted mortality rates increased significantly during the study period (p<0,05), might be consistent with the existence of a “geographical gradient” in traffic accidents. That is, while interior and more developed regions have higher number of deaths, so do peripheral regions; but in practice, the later ones have much less regulatory law compliance and enforcement, making it more difficult to know the real picture [23,49] with a bigger risk of death [24,33,36].
Previous studies have identified multiple factors associated with the upward trend of motorcycle’s mortality in Colombia. Researchers from the extinct National Prevention Road Fund, in 2012, estimated improper use of the helmet in 65.5% of motorcyclists, especially in cities greater or equal to 900,000 populations .
These data are consistent with the report from Rodríguez et al. , which in addition to showing low helmet’s wearing in two intermediate cities of the Colombia; they found that in general motorcyclists do not wear helmets because of hygienic and cultural reasons, harsh climatic conditions, and lack of organizational police enforcement.
Moreover, another determining factor that has been identified is the fact that many motorcyclists are not aware of their greater vulnerability to traffic accidents [26,50]. Different behavioral patterns in regional studies from Colombia may somewhat explain why motorcyclists suffer more traffic accidents. Among them, the following factors has been observed: most of motorcyclist do not respect red lights; very often they ride on sidewalks and on pedestrian walkways; they make zigzag driving movements in and out of cars and lanes; they do not wear motorcycle helmet, or if they do, they do not wear it correctly or do not wear the type of helmet that provides the best safety conditions [51-59]. Additionally, few of them use reflective vests even during the hours that it is mandatory; the backseat riders do not use personal protection gear ; very often motorcyclists ride at excessive speed, and they do not stay in before the lane when they stop at red lights [27,32,39,53,60-63].
However, it is known that such risky behaviors are not exclusive of Colombian motorcyclists; various authors have described similar patterns in other parts of the world. Patterns of zigzagging through traffic, talking on a mobile phone while driving, not wearing a motorcycle helmet or using it incorrectly, not using reflective gear, violating traffic regulations, speeding, and driving under the influence of alcohol have been positively associated with the increasing risk of fatalities that motorcyclists around the world are frequently expose to, when involved in traffic accidents [1,7,25,49].
Moreover, the results obtained in this study allowed to corroborate that in Colombia, similarly to other countries, deaths related to traffic accidents, especially in motorcyclists, are concentrated on men . In this regard, it has been reported that men are more likely to drive at high speeds or to do so under the influence of alcohol (that is, with patterns of speeding, drinking and driving), having much more confidence while driving in risky situations [64-73].
But, unfortunately, this study fails to provide specific interpretations of how gender roles determine activities such as drinking and driving, exposure to risky behaviors and the likelihood of dying from road collisions. The high incidence of mortality rate among population 15 and 34 years of age could be related to limited skills and abilities to drive , lack of knowledge of road safety rules , lack of technical expertise to make decisions in risky situations and “overconfidence” [75-78].
This study has as framework a generalized linear model where the dependent variable is a numeric variable; which it is supported by current research, indicating the utility of such approaches for studies in public health with this kind of features [79-84]. There are some critics that mention possible risks and limitations with this approach. Even so, it is considered that these aspects cannot be related to the present study, because the authors followed the assumptions of equal dispersion and integrity of the data, attributes that have been left intact. However, another alternative could have been the application of time series analysis, but there are not complete, and in detail information to do so.
Another important constraint in this study is not having further details of the events, such as type of motorcycle, speeding patterns, drinking and driving behavior, wearing of helmets, severity of injuries etc. [85-91]. On the other hand, the records were, also, not correlated, with basic information such as policies to ease purchase of vehicles, price of gas, motorcyclist’s perceptions and preferences for using a type of vehicle, among others [92-95].
Finally, this research has the typical limitations of population studies that are based on secondary source, as the current example with death certificate records; which usually have considerable errors, such as in recording, coding and classification —among others [54,96,97]. However, the authors believe that in this case these potential data flaws are highly controlled by the strict validation and reclassification systems used by the Colombian National Administration Department of Statistics (DANE). As well, another important limitation is that this kind of source with secondary mortality records does not identify causes, risk factors and/or possible determining factors regarding the occurrence of motorcyclist fatalities. For instance, there are not identifications of factors such as social and cultural variables (level of income and driving practices, etc.); individual variables (drinking and driving habits, risky behaviors, wearing of a motorcycle helmet, driving skills, type of helmet used, etc.), vehicle variables (make, model, size, etc.), and environmental variables (speed, road lighting, road signs, appropriateness of road infrastructure, etc.). Similarly, analysis using socioeconomic factors or other social determinants could not be made, because the records shown more than 20% of underreporting data in crucial variables like the deceased’s social strata and education level; therefore, this type of important evaluation had to be excluded.
Despite of all possible limitations, this work is integrated to the body of evidence on this increasing issue, generating hypotheses related to the behavioral Colombian’s motorcycle fatalities and high mortality. Subsequently, it is a way to opening up the discussion for the imperative need of designing and implementing a series of interventions aimed at mitigating this catastrophic result in deaths. Combined aspects that obviously are having a high impact on the social and economic development of the country.
After several months of delay, the Colombian Government, led by the Ministry of Transportation, in December 2015, set up the National Agency for Road Safety, which is expected to promote effectively the policies described on the National Plan for Road Safety in Colombia, during 2014-2021 period, addressing them at the national level and monitoring the implementation at the regional and local level [98,99].
Additionally, it is important to point out that the Colombian government must not be repeating the same mistakes, designing and implementing policies at the regional and local levels that have little chance of law-abiding or being implemented; as it is the case, currently, with much sectorial legislation. It is also imperative that the Colombian government improves the process of control and regulation, adjusting in better way the access, sale and availability of motorcycles, in addition to better parameters of distributing driving licenses and driving schools that issues them. Also, vital aspects such as the compliance and enforcement of the road legislation must be strengthened, along with the mandatory mechanical and technical check of all types of vehicles . It is essential to regulate and penalize patterns of risky behaviors for motorcyclists, as well as for all road players, enforcing the compliance of the legislation in coherence, consistent and articulated way .
Finally, it should not be allowed that drivers with a history of multiple breaches and traffic infractions keep doing so; therefore, exemplifying mechanisms for punishment and suspension of licenses must be generated, in order to avoid putting at risk the life of themselves as well as the other road users. These recommendations coincide with the ones included on the most recent report of road safety from the WHO in 2015; in which the report mention the fact that “countries that have been more successful in reducing the number of deaths due to traffic, have achieved this goal by making improvements in legislation, applying and executing the enforcement of those rules, and by building and making safer roads and vehicles" .
All Published work is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution 4.0 International License
Copyright © 2019 All rights reserved. iMedPub LTD Last revised : April 25, 2019